Tool Review: Rockler’s new handplanes
Chris Gochnour tested four of Rockler's new high-end handplanes–a No. 4 smoothing plane, a low-angle jack plane, a block plane, and a three-in-one shoulder plane.Rockler has introduced a new line of high-end handplanes under the name Bench Dog. I tested four of their models, a No. 4 smoothing plane, a low-angle jack plane, a block plane, and a three-in-one shoulder plane.
The planes have good bones, with bodies cast from durable ductile iron and hefty blades made of good steel that is, for the most part, ground well, with the backs requiring only 5 to 10 minutes of lapping and a few more to hone. The planes were cleanly machined, although not all soles were flat or sides square. They sport nicely shaped mahogany totes and knobs, and many of the fittings are polished brass.
Once tuned up, three of the four performed well, felt solid, and adjusted tightly—performing close to the best on the market. The block plane required only a bit of sole lapping because of a crown. The No. 4’s chip breaker needed some fettling to fit better to its blade. The low-angle jack’s blade had a noticeable back bevel; and, when the blade was set parallel to the sole, it was skewed relative to the adjustable toe. But the plane still performed quite well.
The shoulder plane was the outlier. It started with too many strikes against it to warrant the time needed to set it up. The sides were not square to the sole, the blade was narrower than the body, and the bullnose attachment lacked alignment pins.
—Chris Gochnour is a contributing editor and furniture maker in Salt Lake City.
Fine Woodworking Recommended Products
Stanley Powerlock 16-ft. tape measure
Veritas Wheel Marking Gauge
Veritas Precision Square
Comments
Another reason to go big or go home meaning spend a few extra ponies and get what you need to get it done the first time.
I bought the #4 and the block plane back in June 2019 but do to life I didnt take them out of the boxes for 3 months. I had read many many reviews and at the time most were very positive. Not the case for me.
At first I was happy, till I needed to sharpen the blade on the #4. I then discovered that both blades were warped. Tried to get them replaced and rockler refused. I also found like in the article above the soles were not flat and the sides were not square. It took about 5hrs for the block , and about 6hrs for the #4 on diamond plates to get them true.
I have since replaced them. Yes spend a few more dollars and get Veritas or Lee Valley
Log in or create an account to post a comment.
Sign up Log in