My trusty Porter Cable 382 5″ random orbit sander gave up the ghost yesterday. I have a substantial investment in the appropriate 5 hole disks and wonder if anyone has an alternative sander (I’m open to other brands) that would accept these disks?
Discussion Forum
Get It All!
UNLIMITED Membership is like taking a master class in woodworking for less than $10 a month.
Start Your Free TrialCategories
Discussion Forum
Digital Plans Library
Member exclusive! – Plans for everyone – from beginners to experts – right at your fingertips.
Highlights
-
Shape Your Skills
when you sign up for our emails
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. -
Shop Talk Live Podcast
-
Our favorite articles and videos
-
E-Learning Courses from Fine Woodworking
-
-
Replies
Are you sure you have a PC 382? That model is still available but it is an 8 hole pattern. The old 333's had a 5 hole disk, but I think you will be hard pressed to find something that uses that pattern today. If it is only for light use I think B&D has a model BDERO100 or you may want to see if a new PC 382 can be fitted with a replacement disk from a PC 333 which are still readily available. The 3 attachment screws seem to be on the same bolt circle so I would say the chances are pretty good that you could make that work.
I use a Bosch GEX33-5N and a Makita BO5941-K. Both perform well. I tend to use the Makita more because the front handle can be rotated to different positions which I really like. That said the trigger lock button loc. wasn't very well considered. I takes a bit to "master it" - after some use it is manageable. Makita needs special hose adapter which is easy to get.
I've owned PC, DeWalt, Bosch and Makita 5-inchers. Unless you're a professional, in that price/performance range I'd go with whichever of the name brands you find at a good sale price first.
I don't think the OP is looking for recommendations on RO sanders, but is asking if anyone know of a model that accepts the old PC 5 hole disc's which he seems to have an abundance of and would like to continue to use.
Take your five hole pad off, and see if it will fit on a new PC with an 8 hole pad. The pads are meant to be replaced when they wear out, and I would bet that the 5 and 8 hole pads are otherwise identical.
Except for Festool, everything seems to be 8 hole these days. I wouldn't invest in any more 5 hole paper.
I have had tools that needed parts and I couldn't find the part . I would put a search out on ebay for a used one to use for parts. Eventually one would come up and at a price that I though was fair so I would buy it.As it turned out everytime I did that when I received the tool it turned out to be in better condition than the one I was trying to repair. It makes sense actually. If you burned up a tool its because you use it, someone is getting rid of a tool because they dont use it. Craigslist can be good for that as well but for small items it seems that when I find something it's a 2 hour drive to get it.
Don't forget that you can always punch additional holes in your existing 5 hole paper discs. No harm. Works just fine. Sharpen the edges of a piece of thin wall steel tubing the right size, make a template, strike the tube a couple of times with a wood mallet and it makes a clean hole.
Not really 'on-message' but I've quit buying holey paper and buy Abranet instead. Works out about the same price or a bit less per unit of sanding done as decent quality paper but the dust collection is phenomenal and as it's all hole, there is no irritation of alignment. I'll only buy the paper stuff in future if I'm in a big hurry...
I had the identical issue two years ago.
Ended up buying a pair of these for the 5 hole discs:
Sackorange Hook and Loop Hand Sanding Block - Sanding Pad - 5 Inch Hook Backing Plate for Sanders or Polishers(5 inch) https://a.co/d/56djCaH
And then bought 8 hole discs for the new sander.
Mike
This forum post is now archived. Commenting has been disabled