Replies

1. 
   Byron | Jan 28, 2003 12:41am | #1

   I have the makita RF1101 router, not the plunge base.  I am really happy with the fixed base router.  My father has the Bosch router kit and he seems to like it.  As with most routers, look for positioning of the on/off switch, where the release mechanism is for the plunge lock and the collets that come with the unit.  I have heard (tool reviews from magazines) that the makita plunge base is not as good as others, but for the purpose you mentioned, I would think that it would do fine.  The makita is not too noisy, has a soft start, comes with two collets, has a micro adjustment, has a lot of power, and there is a manufacturing plant in Georgia.  I am not as versed with the Bosch brand. 

1. 
   timberrattler | Jan 28, 2003 04:46pm | #2

   I was dreading a response like yours because like I said I was leaning Bosch.

   thanks

   Mark

2. 
   bsutton12 | Jan 28, 2003 07:57pm | #3

   I just bought the Bosch package with the 1617VSR and fixed and plunge bases.  Be aware that Bosch has two packages; one variable speed and one fixed speed (if that is important to you).  I needed a router for large panel raising bits.  After buying a speed control unit for my 3 HP Makita, I discovered it wouldn't take a 3-1/2 in. bit.

   I really like the Bosch.  Seems very well thought out.  Features like the variable speed, micrometer depth adjustment (which works very well in a router table) and the quick release clamp are very useful.

3. 
   user-212595 | Jan 28, 2003 08:19pm | #4

   Any reason why you are counting out Dewalt's new combo. pack?

1. 
   timberrattler | Jan 28, 2003 09:19pm | #5

   No. I haven't seen it advertised. The Bosch and Makita were featured prominently in a recent issue of tool crib and the prices seemed fair.

1. 
   user-212595 | Jan 29, 2003 04:03pm | #6

   It is definitely worth a look.  Two models - 1 3/4 and 2 1/4 hp.  Both have soft start but I believe only the bigger of the two has variable speed.  I bought the 2 1/4 a couple of months ago and love it.  It carries forward Dewalts smooth plunge mechanism.  I believe you can get the 2 1/4 for about $250, if not less.

1. 
   mikkimel | Jan 29, 2003 04:24pm | #7

   The new issue of American Woodworker magazine (the router issue) has a review of four router of the plunge/fixed base routers. 

   The Bosch won.

   Just an FYI, i've never tried any of them.

1. 
   sailalex | Jan 29, 2003 04:29pm | #8

   FWW also ran a test about a year ago and the Bosch was "the One"; I bought a Bosch package but I have used only the plunge router and then not much. I found nothing that was a problem; well done unit.

2. 
   timberrattler | Jan 29, 2003 04:33pm | #9

   thanks boys