Dedicated Router Table Router vs Router on a cast-iron Table Saw extension wing
jrm200
| Posted in New To Woodworking on
I could use some real world advice on whether I should get a dedicated router table or replace the left wing on my Platinum Unisaw, with an 18″ cast iron piece with a router plate cut-out in it. My initial thought was the Biesemeyer Fence would be sufficient to serve as the router fence. However, I think if it was such a great idea, there would be a lot more table saw extensions being sold than dedicated router tables. I think I might be missing something here. Oh, I already have a Porter Cable 7518 router.
thanks for your help.
Best regards,
JRM
Replies
Router
If you're tight for space - go with the wing. Otherwise build your own router table. I made my router table the same height as my table saw and it serves as an extention for the saw table top when cutting a full sheet of plywood. I also have a split fence and can use the router horizontal - you can mount a speed control on your shop built table and storage below for bits, wrenches etc. It's easier to move the table around when feeding stock through if space is an issue-
SA
Space versus efficiency
I agree that using the extension is the way to go if space is an issue. But if you've got the room, a router table is a better choice. Your table saw fence will have limited capabilities for router use, a fence designed for router use is much more versatile. Another huge consideration is dust collection/control. Routers are huge dust makers and your shop can quuickly be overwhelmed with the mess. Even the most simple portable router tables incorporate rudimentary dust collection.
Build your own table. I'm a strong advocate of building your own tables and jigs. It helps strengthen your skills, is designed specifically for your shop, and will be a source of pride for years to come. Do a search for router tables and you will find a vast array of designs and configurations. I built mine based on the updated Norm Abrams table. It was fun to build, and is a joy to use.
Choices
The TS extension wing mounted router seems like a nifty idea, particularly if you are limited on space. As noted, however, the practical problem is that once the router side is set up with a bit in place, the TS side has very limited use. So, if you need to cut another board, you may have to clear the router setup. Naturally, that usually happens only after you've spent a lot of time "dialing in" a precise setup on the router. ;-)
Deleted
This forum post is now archived. Commenting has been disabled