Okay so I’m a newish woodworker getting ready to build my assembly table. I’ve looked at various options here and on YouTube, etc. and I’ve noticed there seem to be two popular styles. 1) a melamine topped torsion box that’s completely flat on top with no clamping options (eg dog holes or t-track, etc.), or 2) a plywood top with t-track or dog holes. So basically my question is: do I need clamping on my assembly table or not? I like the idea of the melamine torsion box for flatness and ease of cleanup, but am I likely to regret not having clamping options (other than the edges)? TIA
Discussion Forum
Get It All!
UNLIMITED Membership is like taking a master class in woodworking for less than $10 a month.
Start Your Free TrialCategories
Discussion Forum
Digital Plans Library
Member exclusive! – Plans for everyone – from beginners to experts – right at your fingertips.
Highlights
-
Shape Your Skills
when you sign up for our emails
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. -
Shop Talk Live Podcast
-
Our favorite articles and videos
-
E-Learning Courses from Fine Woodworking
-
-
Replies
My assembly table is more multifunction than only assembly and made from 2x6s edge glued. I clamp a planing stop on one end and smooth boards with my planes, just to give one example. After I built it, I added a router and router lift. I don't have any t-tracks so I clamp my router fence to each end of the table. I also use it to glue panels and just wipe up or scrape off the glue drips. I can't imagine trying to do what I do without clamping options.
Depends on what you do.
I have a plain flat top table with overhang. If I need a clamp I usually need something strong so a quick grip clamp onto the edge is used.
I also have a separate bench against a wall with a traditional vice.
I don't have t track in mine.
My assembly table is a hollow core door with Masonite screwed onto it. I have never seen the need to clamp stuff to it during glue ups.
This will certainly vary with now you work. I have clamping options in mine.
In other words, you'll figure it out as you go along making things, on your table, and say to yourself "I need to clamp this". And then you'll see whether you need to put in some dogholes, or whatever.
My assembly table is usually my main workbench (72” x 36”). I upgraded the top a few years ago (2” thick beech slab). I made sure to drill two rows of dog holes down the length of the bench and along the front apron (6” wide). Based on recommendations from other Woodworker’s I now use holdfasts as my primary means of clamping at my bench. They are easy to use, hold well and give me all the flexibility I need at any spot on the top (for both assembly and general planing, drilling, routing etc functions). There are different companies that make holdfasts and different styles. I bought two from Gramercy and am very happy with the performance. You just need to make sure the top you use is thick enough (1-3/4” thick top is recommended)for them to work properly. Just yesterday I had to work on a 3” square table leg that was positioned on 2 large V-blocks I made to allow me to work on the 45degree position. One holdfast was enough to secure the leg sitting on the blocks and allowed me to reposition the leg quickly. Using clamps would not have given me the same flexibility and always takes more time and effort to reposition. The same would apply for assembly in that you could install supports anywhere on the top to aid in an assembly process because we never have enough hands during this stage!
I got by with no surface clamping methods for years, building mostly cabinets. I added T tracks and they are handy, but aggravating b/c they collect glue drops, small screws, pencils, etc.
You can do a torsion box and still have MFT type clamp holes.
But anything that drops thru the hole, like the last brass screw in the hinge pack, is gone!
Not knowing what your work methods are, but in general consider building a ww’ing bench with a thick top.
This forum post is now archived. Commenting has been disabled