*
I just finished a jewelry box made out of white oak. I have put an oil based stain on and a few coats of polyurethane. I am not satisfied with the appearance and I read somewhere that it is not a good idea to rub this type of finish because the layers do not fuse together and if you rub through one layer it will be noticeable. I am considering removing this finish and putting on laquer. Anybody who is knowledgable about these things can hopefully give some advice about the fusion of polyurethanes or recommend a different finish appropriate for a jewelry box. Also wondering if you can use oil over a finish. I have always thought you can’t because stain seals and the oil must be absorbed, but everyone in this forum seems very knowledgable so I thought I might ask. Thanks
Discussion Forum
Get It All!
UNLIMITED Membership is like taking a master class in woodworking for less than $10 a month.
Start Your Free TrialCategories
Discussion Forum
Digital Plans Library
Member exclusive! – Plans for everyone – from beginners to experts – right at your fingertips.
Highlights
-
Shape Your Skills
when you sign up for our emails
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. -
Shop Talk Live Podcast
-
Our favorite articles and videos
-
E-Learning Courses from Fine Woodworking
-
-
Replies
*
Its not a good idea to put pure oils over a sealed surface. Oils build gummy and soft.
I would suggest spray aerosol lacquers like Deft or Behlen. The best feature of lacquer - besides the quick dry time is the fusion between coats. When you rub out the lacquer - no rubbing through.
Lacquer also rubs out better than poly.
Jeff Jewitt
If lacquer is too objectionable due to the smell -- try dewaxed shellac. It has all the features of lacquer but is a tad less durable.
*Thanks for the advice. Hope it turns out well.
*I have successfully rubbed out multi layer poly applications. Rub through won't occur if second and following poly coats are applied before complete polymerization of the under layer has taken place. I rub out with wet silcarb up to 600 grit, followed by auto polishing compound. That said, I prefer to use a sprayed on nitro or CAB acrylic lacquer over water soluble aniline dye stain, rubbed out with auto compound if necessary. Usually not necessary.I suggest you strip the old finish with a MEC stripper, washed with naptha, then one of the above finishes.Clint Searl
*Distressing:Looking for definitive guide on distressing furniture to achieve European or "Old World" finish.
*I just completed my first jewelry box from Walnut. What type of filler is best before a coat of Danish Oil?
*We have used 2 coats of Danish oil followed by 2 coats of beeswax on our jewelry boxes. The finish is beautiful but the odor is very strong and offensive even after leaving it exposed to the open air for over two weeks. Any suggestions on how to eliminate the strong odor ?
*Bob, it should not be the Danish oil causing the problem. What sort of solvent did you use for your beeswax? FWIW, while I have seen tons of recipes over the years for formulating one's own wax polishes, I tend to trust the companies who've been at it for decades, some over 100 years. Try stripping the wax with mineral spirits and start over with a commercial brand like Mylands, Fiddes, or Briwax.As for Brendan's original question, I'd consider the use of a wiping varnish. Don't laugh, but Formby's tung oil varnish in either gloss or semi-gloss is as good as any you'll find. The desired amount of build is easy to control. A jewelry box might look more appropriate with the gloss type, but that's a matter of your own taste of course.I have found that the Formby varnish rubs out fine. It is also packaged in a convenient size for small projects. Success is practically guaranteed if you simply follow the package directions....When working Danish oil, you typically would again, follow the package directions fairly closely for the application of three coats following the instructions for drying times and using common sense. After the last coat is fully cured, you could apply two coats of wax polish, again following package directions explicitly and buff each coat to your heart's content by hand with a soft cloth.Your project will look just fine.
*SeaFin Teak Oil/Watco. I'm finishing a Eastern Maple table top and I want to use something like these. I intend to apply Tung Oil first. Are these varnishes and do they yellow a lot more than a lacquer. I do not want a "built up" finish.
This forum post is now archived. Commenting has been disabled