Replies

1. 
   SteveSchoene | Jul 10, 2006 03:33am | #1

   Do you really want to obscure the subtle grain of cherry with a gel stain?  Cherry will darken naturally in quite a short period of time, so if you get it right to begin with in a year or two it will be too dark.

   I am always a bit skeptical of Minwax products, but I can't actually say I've compared the brands you  mentioned.  And definately not on cherry. 

2. 
   SARGEgrinder47 | Jul 10, 2006 04:18am | #2

   Evening Brian. I have used both and prefer the Bartley's. Tried it several years ago and unless something better gets my attention, will stick with it.

   But..... Steve has a point about the cherry. Stop and thing about it. Which stain would you use on it? Perhaps a nice coat of cherry stain to make it look like cherry? I think you get the point. :>)

   Regards...

   SARGE.. g-47

3. 
   mapleman | Jul 10, 2006 06:04am | #3

   BM,

   I have used bartleys and general on maple and cherry, I prefer the general because the colors seem to be a little darker or richer. Both  do a great job of staining very even, and preventing blotchiness.  By the way, if you want to stain cherry, go for it. Some pieces I have built were stained, some left natural. Both look good. The cherry will darken a little over time, more if the piece is in direct sunlight - so plan for that accordingly. Good luck.

   Lee