Is there a modern equivalent of hide glue?
Is there a modern glue that can be easily repaired?
What are the disadvantages of using hide glue, and are there other advantages?
If the answers go the way I think they’re going to go, why aren’t we all using hide glue?
Replies
why aren't we all using hide glue?
If my memory serves me right I looked into it and found that the electric glue pots needed to keep hide glue liquid cost over 200 bucks and I thought that Titebond was looking better by the minute. I just didn't want to spend that kind of $ just to see if I liked it or not. That said, when I am in near panic struggling with a bunch of parts and a faster setting glue, I think about the longer open time of hide glue and might reconsider,
I use hide glue frequently. I buy granular glue and heat it up with water in an electric glue pot. Because it takes a while to heat up I have to plan my glue-ups more carefully.
Hide Glue
Jammersix
Go to a big-box store and buy a a little plastic tea pot with a temp control. I use a "Rival Hot Pot". Google it. Find the setting that maintains 145* and mark it. Keep your glue in a canning jar sitting in the hot water. All told - $20. (I'll split the $180 you save with you.)
But - I find hide glue a mess to work with. I've used it several times gluing veneer and banding on demi-lune rails.It is sticky and everything it touches gets sticky. Keep a pail of warm water handy to clean things off.
After is sets (cools) it is hard as a rock and strong. It is reversible but that is not as easy as it sounds.
Frosty
Twenty!
I"m in! I'll do it!
I can afford to spend twenty dollars, glue some stuff up, and then say "this didn't work!" and throw the whole thing away.
I guess I need a meat thermometer to find the 145º, too.
Are there any brands of glue I should try or avoid?
And as it happens, I test my glue joints using the cut-offs most of the time, and I just last night had a whole set fail on me with Titebond! Not sure what happened, I think I may have failed to tighten down the clamps completely.
Hide glue
I think I got mine from Lee Valley. Woodcraft sells it too.
Don't forget the bucket of warm water to clean up. Good luck.
Frosty
olde brown glue
You might also check out Olde Brown Glue: http://www.oldbrownglue.com/index.html
I just ordered some after reading about the product vs. hide glue. OBG is reversible, sounds pretty easy to work with, has a good open time, and about 6 month shelf life unless you refrigerate it. Says you do have to warm it up to 80 degrees but once you do that it's good for the day.
This forum post is now archived. Commenting has been disabled