Replies

1. 
   pins | Jan 12, 2007 04:29am | #1

   I'm not sure you would want to use polymerized tung oil on maple counter tops. I first used it on a cherry dining room table about 25 years ago and it was fine. Formbeys was the only thing available to me at that time, or at least the only product that I knew of.

   But on counter tops, especially maple, which virtually nothing will penetrate and where the finish will take a beating, I think you are better off just using mineral oil.

   Apply it. Let it soak in, rub off excess and then apply more.

   Easy to repair and safe for food.

   I have maple cutting boards that I have used for over 20 years that have no finish at all and they are just as good as new.

   pins

1. 
   jes | Jan 12, 2007 08:48am | #2

   From what I've read (and I'm certainly no expert here), tung oil would provide more durability and protection from water, heat and household chemicals than mineral oil, and require less frequent upkeep. Tung oil, once cured, is rated by the FDA as food safe, and as I understand it is also fairly easy to repair. Am I mistaken? Why do you feel mineral oil would be a superior finish than tung oil?
   I appreciate your input.Jesse David

1. 
   pins | Jan 12, 2007 02:16pm | #3

   Jesse,Everything you said is true. I just don't think you will like counter tops to look like a table top. I don't think a built-up finish is appropriate for counter tops. One chip and you are going to have a lot of work repairing. Same for a slip of a knife.I think if you want to use tung oil, which will do all that you have written, you need to wipe on a couple of thin coats and I would make sure it is not gloss.pins

2. 
   Pondfish | Jan 12, 2007 02:44pm | #4

   You can start with the tung oil, but sand the countertops with nothing higher than 220.  Higher grits can burnish the wood and restrict oil penetration.

   You can leave it at that--repairing an oil finish is as simple as wiping more on.  Or you can topcoat it with something a little more durable.  Unfortunately, a durable topcoat like poly can be scratched but not repaired easily, while a topcoat like nitrocellulose lacquer can be repaired but will yellow with age and make the maple countertops look crummy. 

   Good luck with your choice(s).

    

   Recommending the use of "Hide Signatures" option under "My Preferences" since 2005