Thanks to all who took the time to post you thoughts on hemlock. I appreciate the comments very much and I will absolutely look into another wood.
The composite workbench top comment I like and will follow through on that, again thanks to all.
Bill
Replies
Look for another wood.
“[Deleted]”
A bit soft for a benchtop IMO.
I agree with the too soft view. You do read some folks who propose softer woods for tops so they won't ding their material while working it. This has never made any sense to me.
I also don't avoid composites for work bench tops. I made my first MDF-laminated-to-plywood top about 15 years ago. It served me so well I have used this method ever since.
Two sheets of 3/4" ply for strength (composites don't support themselves over wide spans) and two layers of 3/4" MDF. With a BLO and wax finish they take a lot of abuse and really last.
Go for it. It probably won't be your last work bench, and you definitely won't be afraid to cut/chisel/ drill on it.
Softness is only one drawback, it is prone to splitting between the growth rings, will twist when resawn and easily distributes splinters. It’s the worst wood I had to work with. It’s only quality is that it’s cheap, wonder why ?
Thanks to all who took the time to post you thoughts on hemlock. I appreciate the comments very much and I will absolutely look into another wood.
The composite workbench top comment I like and will follow through on that, again thanks to all.
Bill